Women's Size 9.5

Lucky Shoes carries a great selection of styles from athletic shoes, boots, dress shoes, casual shoes, sandals and slippers. We specialize in helping customers in selecting the right shoes to address foot health concerns that combine fashion with comfort. We carry many brands with 5 different widths, especially hard to find widths. This page features a great selection of shoes from great brands like Hoka, Birkenstock, New Balance, Dansko, SAS, Brooks, Hey Dude, On Running, Stride Rite and many, many more available online now in Women’s Size 9.5.

A Women’s Size 9.5 is typically comparable to a Women’s European Size 40.

ON SALE! See our selection of Women's Size 9.5 shoes that are currently on clearance!

218 products

New Balance 928v3 White
Womens New Balance 928v3 White
Regular Price
$154.99
Sale Price
$154.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 19%
New Balance 990v5 Black With Silver
Womens New Balance 990v5 Black With Silver
Regular Price
$149.97
Sale Price
$149.97
Regular Price
$184.99
Unit Price
per 
Hoka Bondi SR (Slip Resistant) Black/Black
Womens Hoka Bondi SR (Slip Resistant) Black/Black
Regular Price
$175.00
Sale Price
$175.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 30%
New Balance 847v4 Light Aluminum With Vintage I
Womens New Balance 847v4 Light Aluminum With Vintage I
Regular Price
$104.97
Sale Price
$104.97
Regular Price
$149.99
Unit Price
per 
New Balance 928v3 Black
Womens New Balance 928v3 Black
Regular Price
$154.99
Sale Price
$154.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Womens New Balance 1540v3 Gunmetal With Dragonfly
Womens New Balance 1540v3 Gunmetal With Dragonfly
Regular Price
$179.99
Sale Price
$179.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 19%
Womens New Balance 990v5 Grey With Castlerock
Regular Price
$149.97
Sale Price
$149.97
Regular Price
$184.99
Unit Price
per 
Hoka One One Transport Eggnog/Eggnog
Womens Hoka Transport in Eggnog/Eggnog
Regular Price
$150.00
Sale Price
$150.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
On Running Cloudmonster Glacier/Meadow
Womens On Running Cloudmonster Glacier/Meadow
Regular Price
$169.99
Sale Price
$169.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
New Balance 928v3 Bone
Womens New Balance 928v3 Bone
Regular Price
$154.99
Sale Price
$154.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 37%
Vionic Minna Ballet Flat BLACK
Womens Vionic Minna Ballet Flat Black
Regular Price
$74.97
Sale Price
$74.97
Regular Price
$119.95
Unit Price
per 
Save 54%
New Balance FuelCell Rebel v3 Black/Aura/Vibrant Spring Glo
Womens New Balance FuelCell Rebel v3 in Black/Aura/Vibrant Spring Glo
Regular Price
$59.97
Sale Price
$59.97
Regular Price
$129.99
Unit Price
per 
On Running Cloudmonster Acai/Lavender
Womens On Running Cloudmonster Acai/Lavender
Regular Price
$169.99
Sale Price
$169.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Vionic Caroll Ballet Flat BLACK
Womens Vionic Caroll Ballet Flat Black
Regular Price
$119.95
Sale Price
$119.95
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Hoka Bondi SR (Slip Resistant) Wide Black/Black
Womens Hoka Bondi SR (Slip Resistant) Wide Black/Black
Regular Price
$175.00
Sale Price
$175.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Aetrex Jillian Braided Quarter Strap Sandal Navy
Womens Aetrex Jillian Braided Quarter Strap Sandal Navy
Regular Price
$134.95
Sale Price
$134.95
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Womens Vionic Beach Pismo Cream
Regular Price
$70.00
Sale Price
$70.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 58%
Women's Vionic Tokyo Active Sneaker Black
Regular Price
$54.97
Sale Price
$54.97
Regular Price
$129.95
Unit Price
per 
New Balance 1540v3 Silver With Polaris
Womens New Balance 1540v3 Silver With Polaris
Regular Price
$179.99
Sale Price
$179.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 53%
Vionic Ariel Wedge Sandal NUDE
Womens Vionic Ariel Wedge Sandal Nude
Regular Price
$69.97
Sale Price
$69.97
Regular Price
$149.95
Unit Price
per 
Save 31%
Vionic Penelope White
Womens Vionic Penelope Slip On Sneaker White
Regular Price
$89.97
Sale Price
$89.97
Regular Price
$129.95
Unit Price
per 
Womens David Tate Eve Silver
Regular Price
$120.00
Sale Price
$120.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Womens Aetrex Jillian Braided Quarter Strap Sandal Black
Regular Price
$134.95
Sale Price
$134.95
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
On Running Cloud 5 Black/White
Womens On Running Cloud 5 Black/White
Regular Price
$139.99
Sale Price
$139.99
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Save 50%
New Balance Fresh Foam 1080 Unlaced Light Aluminum/Silver Mink/Silver Metallic
Womens New Balance Fresh Foam 1080 Unlaced in Light Aluminum/Silver Mink/Silver Metallic
Regular Price
$79.97
Sale Price
$79.97
Regular Price
$159.99
Unit Price
per 
Hoka One One Bondi SR (Slip Resistant) White
Womens Hoka Bondi SR (Slip Resistant) in White
Regular Price
$175.00
Sale Price
$175.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Hoka Bondi 8 Black/White
Womens Hoka Bondi 8 Black/White
Regular Price
$165.00
Sale Price
$165.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per 
Womens Vionic Winny Lace Up Sneaker White
Regular Price
$125.00
Sale Price
$125.00
Regular Price
Unit Price
per